Tech Note 0023
Recommended hardware for the best performance
MTP/IP applications will transfer data up to the maximum speed of the underlying data path. This will be limited by the slowest component of that path, including network links, hard drives, CPUs, and operating systems. This article provides recommendations for end-point hardware, particularly for ExpeDat and SyncDat servers.
Many factors affect the speed at which data can be transferred. This article focuses on the server-side computing device. See the ExpeDat Performance chapter and other performance Tech Notes for more general discussions of performance issues.
For total network bandwidth of 100 megabits per second or less, any modern desktop computer should provide sufficient hardware throughput. The guidelines below will still be helpful, but at slower network speeds it is more likely that network issues will be the limiting factors in performance.
The slowest component of a computer is usually the data storage device. Hard Disk Drives (HDDs) are often rated according to the speed of their interface, but their real-world transfer speed is much, much slower. Network Attached Storage (NAS) is limited by the speed of its protocol, which is usually much, much slower than the physical interface.
Hard disk drives are particularly vulnerable when multiple files are being accessed at the same time or in rapid succession. The read-write head must move back and forth between files, which typically takes 10 milliseconds per round-trip. At one gigabit per second, 10 milliseconds represents a delay of 1.25 megabytes of data. Because of this seek-time overhead, hard disk drive performance drops off exponentially as the number of concurrent files increases.
For example, a HDD which supports 500 megabits per second of throughput on a single file, might support only 300 megabits per second for two files (150 each), and only 100 megabits per second for three files (33 each). The exact values will vary greatly depending on the drive and filesystem.
To maximize your storage throughput, follow these guidelines:
These storage guidelines apply to any system, but are particularly important for servers supporting multiple concurrent transfers at speeds of 500 megabits per second or more.
For speeds up to about 500 megabits per second, any modern processor of 2 gigahertz or more should be sufficient. Multiple CPUs or cores will be helpful when using encryption or at speeds above one gigabit per second. For speeds of ten gigabits per second or more, at least four cores are recommended (eight with encryption).
There is no speed advantage to 64-bit over 32-bit, but 64-bit may be necessary for SyncDat and ExpeDat clients to process folders with many millions of files.
For speeds above one gigabit per second, larger datagram sizes will greatly reduce operating system overhead and improve efficiency. True ten gigabit networks should support Jumbo frames (9000 MTU) and MTP will automatically switch to Jumbo packets when a transaction exceeds about one gigabit per second.
In some mixed network environments, 10 gigabit or faster network interfaces may be configured with 1500 MTU in order to avoid fragmentation of TCP packets to slower hosts. In such cases, it may be necessary to set MaxDatagram 1408 in the MTP software to disable automatic use of Jumbo packets. See Tech Note 0025 for an example involving AWS EC2 instances.
Always configure your network devices and computers to allow the largest MTU common to all of them. MTP can take advantage of Super Jumbo frames up to 60 kilobytes. See your software documentation for instructions on taking advantage of larger MTU support.
The most recent stable build of any operating system will generally provide better performance than older versions. For high speed networking with Windows, use Windows Server 2012 or later. For the best performance, particularly at multigigabit speeds, avoid Windows.
Even amongst unix systems, some distributions are not tuned for maximum performance "out-of-the-box". For example, FreeBSD requires that you set async mode on the filesystem while many Linux distributions require that you raise the UDP buffer limits and limit filesystem caching (vm.dirty_bytes=125000000). See Tech Note 0035 for more Linux specific advice.
If you are using Linux, FreeBSD, Solaris 8, or Solaris 9, see Tech Note 0024 for important information about UDP buffer limits.
For minimum operating system version requirements, see Tech Note 0004.
MTP/IP network transport normally uses only a few megabytes of memory, but it may consume hundreds of megabytes when writing to slow storage from a fast network. The system should have at least enough RAM to prevent any virtual memory swapping from other applications. For Windows and macOS systems, this is typically 8 gigabytes or more. For Linux systems this is typically 2 gigabytes or more. Use of compression or object handlers with ExpeDat will add 32 megabytes for each such transaction by default. This may become significant on servers processing many such transactions at once.
Having more RAM than needed will not usually improve performance and, especially on Linux systems, may hurt performance. Linux systems with more than 1 gigabyte of RAM should set vm.dirty_bytes=125000000 in /etc/sysctl.conf to reduce the occurence of catastrophic I/O cache flushes. See Tech Note 0035 for details.
For ExpeDat and SyncDat clients, RAM only becomes a significant factor when trying to handle hundreds of thousands of files or more at a time. If your system has at least 2 gigabytes of available RAM, they will be able to handle more than a million files at a time.
For speeds above one gigabit per second, you must verify that all network and storage components are actually capable of the desired speed. For example, a 10 gigabit per second network with only 1 gigabit per second interface cards will not provide more than 1 gigabit per second of performance.
Bonding multiple one gigabit lines is NOT the same as a true multigigabit network.
See Tech Note 0032 for important guidance on setting up multigigabit network paths.
Virtual & Cloud Machines
For virtual machines, the recommendations above apply to whatever portion of the host hardware resources are available to the guest operating system. For the best performance, the virtual machine should be running on dedicated hardware (no other virtual machines) with direct access to a direct-attached hard-drive (not a virtual or network hard-drive). Latency and CPU load may be slightly elevated under these conditions, but otherwise performance should be close to that of the host hardware.
If both the host and guest operating systems have firewalls and you are running MTP/IP server software, then you may need to configure both the host and guest firewalls. See Tech Note 0002 for general firewall instructions.
If the virtual machine is sharing hardware with other virtual machines, if it is using a virtual disk image, or if it is using network attached storage, then disk I/O may be severely impaired for the reasons given above. VMs and instances sharing the same hardware will also share the same network interface which may limit available bandwidth to well below 1 gigabit per second. For cloud instances, using a larger instance size may provide a larger share of the physical bandwidth.
Cloud based machines generally behave like virtual machines, except that you may have more options to scale up the available resources. See Tech Note 0025 for information about Amazon Web Services EC2 instances.
Tech Note History
|Mar||20||2019||Updated MTU and RAM sections|
|Nov||08||2017||Linux storage cache tuning|
Updated RAM advice
Updated cloud advice
|Mar||25||2011||Virtual & Cloud|